Vote on a Logo Below - Win $25 - $500
Vote on a Logo Below - Win $25 - $500
Welcome to Phase 1 of the "strumview" site building contest.
Phase 1: We want your feedback on the logos we created for the new site (see below).
***Remember, the more phases in which you give feedback, the more chances you have to win!
Here's what you need to be involved.
Here's what you need to be involved.
- computer with internet access
- free account to aimadvantage.com (register here for FREE to get started)
*NOTE* if you have already registered and logged in, just keep reading and complete the next phase - your honesty and quality feedback on every stage of the process
- twitter, facebook account and/or blog where you will follow us, friend us, or post updates with links each time you post your critique.
- You must be at least 18 years old to qualify
- You can get started at any time as long as the contest is still open.
We are building the site: http://www.strumviews.com on a Drupal CMS Installation.
Scope of the site: Strumviews.com will be an affiliate marketing website that offers quality, in-depth reviews of different guitars so that interested buyers can get a complete feel for the listed guitars and feel confident about their online purchase before they make the purchase. The site will start relatively small and will only consist of about 3-5 reviews of guitars at different user and price levels. As you follow this process, you should be able to have enough knowledge to replicate the process (with a few aids perhaps).
Here's what we will demonstrate from start to finish:
1- We'll build the website (graphics, pages, etc)
2- We'll build the reviews
3- We'll implement affiliate links in the website so people can make purchases
4- We'll build SEO and other traffic to the site
5- We'll turn the site into a profitable affiliate website while you watch and participate
To complete Phase 1- Please complete these simple steps:
Step 1: Critique each logo you see below and vote on your favorite logo in your comment (must have a registered account here). Your comment must be a minimum of 2 or 3 complete sentences, must give feedback on each logo design, and you must clearly state which one best matches the "Strumviews.com" concept described above.
* not required- but you can add a link to your site if you have one (it must be a family-friendly site)
Step 2: You only need to do at least 1 of the following -pick one to qualify- but you can do more to make it more exciting:
- Tweet this page (can use the "add to any" button below) after you make your comment and invite others in your tweet
- Follow us on twitter http://twitter.com/APSchulman
- Post an invitation of this contest on your facebook account and invite others to join the contest
- Post this contest with a link to this page on a popular contest blog site: to find a contest blog site, simply type in a Google search using one or more of the following: contest blogs, contest sites, competition blogs, competition sites, sweepstakes blogs, sweepstakes sites, add your contest, add your competition, add your give-a-way, add your sweepstakes
Step 3: Send us a quick note via email here telling us you completed phase 1:
Logo 1:
Logo 2:
Logo 3:
Logo 4:
Variations on Logo 3 (from Bob's feedback below)
Logo 4 Variations (from Keith's Feedback)
4a 
4b 
4c 
4d 
4e 
4f 
4g 
4h 
Complete steps 1 through 3 above and be ready to do phase 2.
If you run into issues, please use the feedback tab on the left, site contact form or email and be sure to give your email info so we can help.
Thanks for participating!
Aaron Schulman- aimadvantage.com
***logos are copyright 2011 - Aaron P. Schulman- all rights reserved.
- 10849 reads
Recent Real-Life Email & Relationship Marketing Studies
Comments
Aaron
Wed, 02/23/2011 - 20:12
Permalink
Even more great feedback!
Thanks Keith and Robin. Before you guys made these comments- I actually started working on some banners last night incorporating 4g . . . we were not set on 4g (and still may throw another in the mix from above), but check out what this logo looks like glassed over a bit and on different textured backgrounds (a world of difference!)
here == > http://www.aimadvantage.com/content/strumview-site-building-contest-phase-2
Robin- I agree that having a faded blue and rusty amber orange website would look fairly tacky - so I am in line with you there- just wait until you see it dressed up! (a nice blue / black / and white site will go well with that funky orange)
You guys rock! Thanks for the feedback!
Blessings-
Aaron
Robin
Wed, 02/23/2011 - 14:50
Permalink
Finally getting a chance to
Finally getting a chance to comment.
I like 4g. Nice contrast and easy to read. Not sure I am a fan of the general color scheme. Make sure you are thinking forward to your website. I think at somepoint you are going to want to match the logo colors with your website colors. Do you really want your website to be a combo of the colors in your logo?
Robin
Wed, 02/23/2011 - 14:51
Permalink
I should clarify...
that I mean the colors that are currently in 4g. Not sure that burnt-orange color would be very effective for a website.
keith
Wed, 02/23/2011 - 14:49
Permalink
Yes!!
4g does it for me. That is the one that really has the sophisticated look and the Strumviews really pops out nicely in black on the amber background. The light on light and the dark on dark versions just don't seem to have contrast that grabs the eye.
Aaron
Wed, 02/23/2011 - 11:06
Permalink
Thanks Monty
I do too Monty- I think they have better contrast and are instantly more easy to read.
Thanks for the fb.
Blessings-
Aaron
monty0230
Wed, 02/23/2011 - 10:02
Permalink
good revisions
I like 4e and 4g. My thoughts...
Aaron
Mon, 02/21/2011 - 12:43
Permalink
Thanks Ann
Hi Ann- Thanks for the feedback. I agree- Originally #1 was going to be kind of a neon look but I just threw some sketches together to get things headed in a direction to get some variety and feedback. I am assuming you like the original #4 instead of a variation. . . #2 is clean and solid too- Thanks again-
Aaron
vannhorner
Mon, 02/21/2011 - 12:24
Permalink
I like 4 the best. Love the
Ann Horner
I like 4 the best. Love the graphics. 2 would be my next choice because it so simple and concise. It gets my attention. 1 kind of seems like it is missing something. 3 would be nice with something besides a white background I think.
Ann Horner
Aaron
Sun, 02/20/2011 - 14:27
Permalink
8 crazy variations on logo 4 now!
We now have 8 variations on logo 4. My personal opinion is that 4 f and 4 h do not have enough contrast with the amber (orange) and white to be clear- it's too difficult to read (compared to the others) because the amber and white are both too close in "lightness" - not enough contrast.
>>> CLICK HERE TO JUMP BACK TO LOGO 4 VARIATIONS <<<
Aaron
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 18:34
Permalink
4d with the amber - orange color
Hi Keith- will do. I'll post it when I can get back to the office and tweak it!
Thanks again for the continued feedback.
Aaron
Aaron
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 18:01
Permalink
color wheel at work!
Thanks Monty (Bill) - When I made this logo- I used the color wheel (complimentary colors concept) because I was working with 2 colors. One can also use triads if using 3 colors to make the colors visually balanced and appealing.
See this wheel- that logo you suggest follows some simple "design rules" because the flinty blue and faded orange are complimentary- but something with the words makes it a little hard for me to read- It seems a little too dark to me but the colors follow the "rules".
Thanks for this feedback as well!
Aaron
monty0230
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 17:26
Permalink
same
Still like the colors in 4. 2nd would be 4c. My 2 cents.
Bill
keith
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 17:22
Permalink
logo 4
Try the original one with the lighter buildings? Maybe that would make the Strumviews pop out with the lighter background. I like 4D best, but maybe with the original amber brown color of Strumviews?
keith
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 15:26
Permalink
Number 4 variations
I kept looking at them and started to get that almost dizzy feeling on the variations, sort of the optical illusion type of dizzy. Maybe make the Strumviews red (or some other color) so it stands out a little more and pulls your eyes away from all the lines of it.
Aaron
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 16:12
Permalink
dizzy and dangerous logos
Hi Keith- It may be because they are so small and close together too-
When I get a chance - I might enlarge them to see if that makes a difference first because the variations are smaller than the others. Again- great feedback!
Ok- I enlarged them and spaced them some more. If you right click on any of the logos, you can open any of them in a new window or new tab to view them separately too.
Aaron
Jennifer
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 13:15
Permalink
number 4
I like 4. It makes me feel like I am sitting in a jazz club, smoking a cigar and enjoying a glass of strong chianti while listening to some amazing acoustic guitar sounds.
Aaron
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 13:19
Permalink
wow that's romantic
Wow! That's romantic- (except for the thought of you smoking cigars)
Thanks for the feedback hon-
Love you
Aaron
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 12:10
Permalink
more on logo 4
Thanks Keith- we'll try some variations on logo 4 as well.
OK- we added some variations on Logo 4 and faded the buildings to make it look more like wood grain / buildings and to help see which one was easy to read and also clean and balanced. Let us know your thoughts! Thanks
Aaron
keith
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 09:58
Permalink
logo 4
I like the sophisticated look of Logo 4 also, but as mentioned it is a little strain to read the Strumviews. Maybe try the word in a different color and/or font.
Aaron
Sat, 02/19/2011 - 07:16
Permalink
thank Keith and monty
Hi Keith- I agree - with the changes, it appears that logo 3 looks more balanced or distinct when it is all not the same color. Additionally, I still agree with your first comment that logo #2 is clean and instantly recognizable.
Mont0230 - Glad we have a dissenter! you had said, "Knowing what the logo was for would help me determine what feel was most appropriate." Actually- the description of the site purpose is above the logos on this page under this:
"Scope of the site: Strumviews.com will be an affiliate marketing website. . . ." and so on.
I also like #4 but would prefer it if the words were a little easier to read. . .
Thanks for the feedback- this is helpful and now we're more confused than when we started!
-Aaron
monty0230
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 19:59
Permalink
dissenting view
Knowing what the logo was for would help me determine what feel was most appropriate. That said, I prefer #4. I like the font and the way the buildings work with the guitar.
keith
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 15:29
Permalink
new ones
I like the 2nd one first and the 4th one next of new ones. With that change I would like logo #3 better. The color difference seems to make it flow better to my eyes.
Aaron
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 14:43
Permalink
Thanks Brent
Thanks for the feedback Brent-
Aaron
Brent
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 14:14
Permalink
my pick
#3 red... like my friend Bob!
Aaron
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 13:30
Permalink
Ahh Thanks
Ok. I see what you mean. I made some variations of logo 3 based off of your feedback. Thanks again!
Aaron
Bob Spence
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 13:03
Permalink
"RED"
Bob Spence
I just think on logo 3 that red ink instead of blue for views and the outline would be more dramatic.
Bob Spence
Bob Spence
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 11:30
Permalink
Logo 3
Bob Spence
I find logo 3 to be the most current in design. It comes off the page while the others tend to be stationary. I like the V of views holding up the guitar. It also has the guitar in position for playing. I would try using red instead of blue.
Bob Spence
Aaron
Fri, 02/18/2011 - 11:38
Permalink
Hi Bob- thanks!
Hi Bob, Thanks for the feedback. For those of you who don't know Bob- he is a real artist! You can check out his great stuff here ==> http://adonaiartdesigns.com/ Also Bob- did you mean trying to make the V of the Views red, the whole word "views" red, or everything red? Thanks again- Aaron
keith
Thu, 02/17/2011 - 09:06
Permalink
logos
I like logo number 2 best as it is clean looking and instantly recognizable once seen. Number 4 shows a bit more sophistication, but actually is not as striking as number 2. Number 1 and 3 are a bit harder to read, with number 3 being a disjointed sort of look. Which is Ok if you want to emphasize the Strum. Definitely number 2 as it is more simple and striking being white on black.
Aaron
Thu, 02/17/2011 - 10:45
Permalink
thanks guys!
Thanks Mark1 and Keith. This feedback is exactly the kind we are looking for! It is always valuable to see how other people see it as it gives us a more balanced view. Also- don't forget to share the contest by email, facecbook, or another method using the simple little "share/save" button above (right below the logos and picture of that scary looking guy named Aaron). Great feedback so far!
-Aaron
Mark1
Thu, 02/17/2011 - 07:45
Permalink
I like logo 2 and 3 but. . .
I like logo 2 and 3. The first logo needs some help - it might look better as a neon sign or something. Logo 2 is the cleanest in my opinion, but logo 3 seems to represent somehow that there is some kind of review because of the "v" looking like a check mark. I like logo 4 but the color makes it a bit hard to read. That's it for now.